Home
Store
Opportunity
About Us
Contact Us

G E N E R A L  S T O R E
IN    THE   HEART    OF    AMISH   COUNTRY
A R T H U R                                             I L L I N O I S
1-800-879-2494
Aunt Sarah's
Categories
Search
Displaying All products
Displaying products in category
Displaying search results for

Amish Church Peanut Butter

Our Amish Church Peanut Butter is a one-of-a-kind treat that is sure to please young & old alike. We start with home made peanut butter, then add our special ingredients to make one of the most unforgettable treats you'll ever taste. Try some today!

$2.79

Amish Maple Butter Spread

Much like our Amish Church Peanut Butter, this one-of-a-kind treat is sure to please just about everyone. We start with home made peanut butter, then add our special ingredients with a touch of maple to make one of the most unforgettable treats you'll ever taste. Try some today!

$2.79

Amish Noodles - 1 pound bag

Our noodles start with wholesome grains and are made by hand in small batches. The perfect soup or casserole noodle, they stand up well to just about anything you pair them with.

$9999.00

Amish Popcorn - 1 pound bags

Popcorn lovers rejoice! We bring you a wide variety of all natural, wholesome, tasty popcorn direct from Amish country in the heart of the corn belt in central Illinois. We grow it right here, so you know it's fresh! Pass the salt please....

$9999.00

Amish Rock Candy - 1/2 Pound Bag (8 ounces)

Also referred to as "Shatter Candy", this old fashioned treat harkens back to a simpler time when this traditional Amish candy was made in small batches, poured out into large sheets and allowed to cool. Once cool, the hardened candy was broken into small, bite sized pieces, then dusted with powdered sugar for a true old-fashioned treat. Try some today!

$2.49

Aunt Sarah's Amish Jam - 16 ounce jars

Our jams, jellies and fruit butters are all locally made using only the freshest fruits available harvested at the very peak of ripeness using the time honored recipes and methods of the Amish to ensure you get the best possible product.

$4.59

Aunt Sarah's Amish Jam - 8 ounce

Our jams, jellies and fruit butters are all locally made using only the freshest fruits available harvested at the very peak of ripeness and, using the time honored recipes of the Amish to ensure you get the best possible product.

$2.79

Aunt Sarah's Amish Jelly - 16 ounce jars

Our jellies, jams and fruit butters are all locally made using only the freshest fruits available harvested at the very peak of ripeness using the time honored recipes and methods of the Amish to ensure you get the best possible product.

$4.59

Aunt Sarah's Amish Jelly - 8 ounce jars

Our jellies, jams and fruit butters are all locally made using only the freshest fruits available harvested at the very peak of ripeness using the time honored recipes and methods of the Amish to ensure you get the best possible product.

$2.69

Aunt Sarah's Famous Homemade Fudge

Made in Aunt Sarah's kitchen in small, individual batches, this famous fudge is made the old fashioned way, using the time-honored traditional recipes from the Old Order Amish - famous for their craft of candy making. This is by far our most popular item and we think after just one taste, you'll agree Aunt Sarah's Famous Homemade Fudge will be one of your favorites too!

$9999.00

Aunt Sarah's Famous Homemade Sugar Free Fudge

Made in Aunt Sarah's kitchen in small, individual batches just like our regular fudge, this sugar free fudge is also made the old fashioned way, using the time-honored traditional recipes from the Old Order Amish - famous for their craft of candy making. We think you'll love our sugar free fudge - try some today!

$11.95

Aunt Sarah's Fruit Butter

Our fruit butters are all locally made using only the freshest fruits available harvested at the very peak of ripeness using the time honored recipes and methods of the Amish to ensure you get the best possible product. Everything is better with fruit butter on it!

$2.49

Aunt Sarah's Fruit Butter - 1 Pint Jar

Our fruit butters are all locally made using only the freshest fruits available harvested at the very peak of ripeness using the time honored recipes and methods of the Amish to ensure you get the best possible product. Everything is better with fruit butter on it!

$3.09

Aunt Sarah's Home Made Pancake Syrup - 1 Pint Bottle

Remember those weekend mornings as a child when you'd wake up to the wonderful smell of hotcakes on the griddle? Aunt Sarah always had several of her amazing home made syrups to smother those hotcakes in. Now you can have her famous home made syrup too. Batter up!

$9999.00

Aunt Sarah's Sugar Free Fruit Butter

Famous for their canning and preserving techniques, our Amish friends and partners still make their all natural fruit butters sweetened with the fruit's own juice instead of sugar. True love is a jar of fruit butter you only share with yourself...

$2.69

Aunt Sarah's Sugar Free Jam - 16 ounce

Famous for their canning and preserving techniques, our Amish friends and partners still make their all natural fruit jams sweetened with the fruit's own juice instead of sugar.

$4.99

Aunt Sarah's Sugar Free Jam - 8 ounce

Famous for their canning and preserving techniques, our Amish friends and partners still make their all natural fruit jams sweetened with the fruit's own juice instead of sugar.

$3.19

Baby Swiss Wheel

The Original Baby Swiss - Our Best Seller
This is the cheese that put us on the map! Just one taste and you'll understand why this is no ordinary Swiss! The delicate flavor is very smooth, soft & milder than what you'd expect in a typical Swiss cheese. Each wheel is still made with the secret Amish recipe perfected over 50 years ago. Every wheel is carefully aged to guarantee the flavor and appearance are perfect. For cooking, snacking, hor d'oeuvres or simple sandwiches, our Original Baby Swiss has no equal. You can't go wrong sending this award-winning cheese to friends, family or even yourself!

$9999.00

Breakfast Gift Box

Saturday morning and the hotcakes are on the griddle, all you need is a breakfast gift box to make everyone happy! Each gift box includes a pint of our Amish Church Peanut Butter, 1/2 pint of our local honey and one bottle of our homemade Maple, Bluebarry, Strawberry, Red Raspberry, Cherry or Blackberry pancake syrup.

$18.95

Fruit Butter Assortment - Four 8 ounce Jars

An assortment of four 8 ounce jars of our famous Amish Fruit Butter. You choose from Apple, Peach, Apricot, Plum, Cranberry, Cherry, Strawberry/Rhubarb, Pumpkin, Blueberry, Strawberry or Pear

$18.95

Fruit Butter Assortment - Six 8 ounce Jars

An assortment of six 8 ounce jars of our famous Amish Fruit Butter. You choose from Apple, Peach, Apricot, Plum, Cranberry, Cherry, Strawberry/Rhubarb, Pumpkin, Blueberry, Strawberry or Pear

$25.95

Home Made Salsa - 1 pint jar

CAUTION: This is no ordinary salsa - use extreme care when opening as the bounty of fresh flavors may be a bit overwhelming to anyone who hasn't experienced our unique, home made blends of special herbs, spices, fruits and vegetables. Ole!

$9999.00

Honey - 1 Pint jar (16 ounces)

Our locally produced honey is certainly a toothsome treat. All-natural in nature, unspoiled with chemicals, sweeteners or preservatives.

$9999.00

Honey 1/2 Pint Jar (8 ounces)

Our locally produced honey is certainly a toothsome treat. All-natural in nature, unspoiled with chemicals, sweeteners or preservatives.

$9999.00

Jam Gift Assortment - Four 8 ounce Jars

An assortment of four 8 ounce jars of our famous Amish Fruit Jam. Choose from a large assortment of flavors, including; Apricot, Boysenberry, Peach, Strawberry/Rhubarb, Blackberry, Cherry, Red Raspberry, Black Raspberry, Dutch Apple, Rhubarb, Blueberry, Strawberry and Hot Pepper

$19.95

Jam Gift Assortment - Six 8 ounce Jars

An assortment of four 8 ounce jars of our famous Amish Fruit Jam. Choose from a large assortment of flavors, including; Apricot, Boysenberry, Peach, Strawberry/Rhubarb, Blackberry, Cherry, Red Raspberry, Black Raspberry, Dutch Apple, Rhubarb, Blueberry, Strawberry and Hot Pepper

$27.95

Microwave Popcorn

Our Amish friends don't microwave popcorn, but that didn't keep us from developing a microwavable popcorn that tastes as good as the old fashioned variety. Try some today, we think you'll agree it's worth 'popping' in the microwave!

$1.29

Mustard - 9 ounce

Our Amish made gourmet mustard is great with a piece of cheese on its own or on a cracker. Made with locally grown ingredients, our mustard is perfect to brush on your favorite piece of meat or to combine with our gourmet vinegars to create your own salad dressing.

$2.69

Old fashioned Cashew Brittle - 1 Pound Bag

Cashew lovers - this one is for you!
Like our peanut brittle, this delectable favorite is thin, light and chock full of cashews. A favorite of young and old alike. Remember to order plenty!

$9999.00

Old fashioned Hand-Pulled Taffy - 1/2 Pound Bag

Taffy just like they used to make at the fair or amusement park. This hand-pulled taffy is made using the same time-honored traditions of old, bursting with the flavor and texture you know and love. Try some today!

$9999.00

Old fashioned Peanut Brittle - 1 Pound Bag

When was the last time you had good homemade brittle? If you don't remember, let us help you never forget with this thin, light traditional favorite chock full of tasty nuts. A favorite of young and old alike. Remember to order plenty!

$9999.00

Old-fashioned Pie Filling - 1 quart jar

If you love pie, you'll love Aunt Sarah's Old-fashioned pie filling. Our famous pie filling is bursting with all natural ingredients and ready to 'pour and bake' into your favorite crust. It's also great on ice cream, waffles or straight from the jar,... we won't tell!

$9999.00

Popcorn Gift Box

This Gift box is perfect for a quiet night in with family, friends or,... by yourself if you are not the sharing kind (we understand,... really we do). All told, you get 2 - 1 pound bags of our Amish Popping Corn, popcorn salt and our special butter topping - enjoy!

$20.95

Popcorn Salt - 4 ounce white or yellow

Love popcorn? If so, you"ll absolutely love our special salts & seasonings. Made with the popcorn aficionado in mind, these gourmet toppings are sure to appease your taste buds!

$2.49

Popcorn Toppings - 8 ounce

Love popcorn? You"ll absolutely love our special salts & seasonings. Made with the popcorn aficionado in mind, these gourmet toppings are sure to appease your taste buds!

$4.59

Sugar Free Fruit Butter Assortment - Four 8 ounce Jars

An assortment of four 8 ounce jars of our famous Amish Fruit Butter. You choose from Apple, Peach, Apricot, Plum, Cranberry, Cherry, Strawberry/Rhubarb, Pumpkin, Blueberry, Strawberry or Pear

$19.95

Sugar Free Fruit Butter Assortment - Six 8 ounce Jars

An assortment of six 8 ounce jars of our famous Amish Fruit Butter. You choose from Apple, Peach, Apricot, Plum, Cranberry, Cherry, Strawberry/Rhubarb, Pumpkin, Blueberry, Strawberry or Pear

$27.95

Sugar Free Fruit Jam Gift Assortment - Four 8 ounce Jars

An assortment of four 8 ounce jars of our famous Amish Fruit Jam. Choose from a large assortment of flavors, including; Apricot, Peach, Strawberry/Rhubarb, Blackberry, Red Raspberry, Black Raspberry, Blueberry and Strawberry

$21.95

Sugar Free Fruit Jam Gift Assortment - Six 8 ounce Jars

An assortment of four 8 ounce jars of our famous Amish Fruit Jam. Choose from a large assortment of flavors, including; Apricot, Peach, Strawberry/Rhubarb, Blackberry, Red Raspberry, Black Raspberry, Blueberry and Strawberry

$30.95

Sweet Dreams

No doubt about it - this is one S-W-E-E-T gift!
Each gift box includes one pound each of Mixed Rock Candy, Caramel's, Peanut Brittle, Chocolate Fudge and a pint of Church Peanut Butter to to top it all off,... oh my!

$39.95

The Amish Candy Sampler

This assortment includes 1/2 pound each of Mixed Rock Candy, Peanut Brittle and home made caramels. To that we've added 1/2 pint of our famous Church Peanut Butter plus a 1/2 pound of Aunt sarah's amazing Pecan Fudge - all arranged beautifully in a gift box complete with a special card!

$24.95

The Amish Delight

A great assortment of goodies from Amish country. The gift box includes 1 pound of Summer sausage, 1 1/2 pound each of Colby and Pepper Jack cheeses, 1/2 pound of Mixed Shatter Candy and 1/2 pint each of Amish Peanut Butter, Apple Butter and Strawberry Jam all in a festive gift box.

$35.95

The Arthur Sampler

One of our most popular gift choices and one of the best values going - you're sure to please with this winning combination. Approximately four pounds of cheese in six of our most popular varieties, which include: Colby, Marble, Mild Cheddar, Monterrey Jack, Brick and Pepper Jack. A tasty treat from Amish country.

$29.95

The Executive Gift Basket

THE EXECUTIVE GIFT BASKET
This popular basket makes an excellent gift for family, friends, important clients or business associates.
Includes: two pounds each of the Original Baby Swiss, Pepper Jack, Marble (Colby/Jack), and Mild Cheddar Cheese; One 1-pound summer sausage; One Quart of Amish Apple Butter; One Half Pound each of Chocolate and Vanilla Pecan Fudge; One pound of Old-Fashioned Peanut Brittle; One Half Pound of Home-made Caramels; and One Half Pound of Amish Rock Candy (mixed).
Shipped in a nice wicker basket, add a card with your personal sentiments and you have a memorable gift is
sure to be appreciated.

$99.95

The Grand Sampler

Five delicious Amish-made cheeses, weighing approximately three pound, cut into generous cracker-sized bricks for easy slicing. We've paired that with one pound of our Amish Summer Sausage and a box of premium crackers. Cheeses included are: Marble, Pepper jack, Mild Cheddar, Colby and Monterrey Jack. Cheeses vary in size and weight, approximately 8-10 ounces per variety.

$39.95

The Junior Executive Gift Basket

The same assortment as our popular 'Executive' gift basket with half the portion sizes. This popular basket makes an excellent gift for family, friends, important clients or business associates.
Includes: One pound each of the Original Baby Swiss, Pepper Jack, Marble (Colby/Jack), and Mild Cheddar Cheese; One 8-ounce summer sausage; One Pint of Amish Apple Butter; One quarter pound each of Chocolate and Vanilla Pecan Fudge; One half pound of Old-Fashioned Peanut Brittle; One Quarter Pound of Home-made Caramels; and One Half Pound of Amish Rock Candy (mixed).
Shipped in a very tasteful wicker gift basket. Add a card with your personal sentiments and you'll have a very memorable gift that is sure to be appreciated.

$56.95

The Snacker Party Box

Ready, Set, Snack!
This hefty box features two pounds of our finest cheese including:
Original Baby Swiss, Pepper Jack and Sharp Cheddar
We've also included a 9 oz. jar of Amish Mustard Sauce, a box of crackers and a pound of our famous Amish Summer Sausage. Perfect for the big game or a night in with friends.

$27.95

The Variety Sampler

Four of our favorite cheeses - The Variety Sampler
features four generous half-pound chunks of some of our favorite sampling cheese and makes a great gift.
Individually wrapped packages of Marble, Colby, Pepper Jack and our original Baby Swiss, packaged in an ideal size for snacking or small gatherings.

$24.95

Uncle Eli's Secret BBQ Sauce - 1 Pint Jar

Well folks, we never did get much in the way of recipes from old Uncle Eli, but when we did - it was worth payin' close attention! Made from a closely guarded family recipe with our blend of fresh herbs and special spices, these sauces are definitely the bosses come grillin' time!

$4.69

Wilma's Amish Caramels - 1 Pound Bag

Soft, smooth and melt in your mouth, each batch of caramel is made in the traditional Amish manner. Wilma's secret recipe uses fresh local cream and butter - and that's all we can divulge, after all, it is a secret recipe. The recipe may be secret by the word is out - these caramels are the best around!

$9999.00

Wilma's Amish Caramels - 1/2 Pound Bag

Soft, smooth and melt in your mouth, each batch of caramel is made in the traditional Amish manner. Wilma's secret recipe uses fresh local cream and butter - and that's all we can divulge, after all, it is a secret recipe. The recipe may be secret by the word is out - these caramels are the best around!

$9999.00